Housing Bubble? Blame Greenspan
Housing bubble!? Couldn't be, right? If you're a real estate agent these days uttering such heresy would be enough to sink your career. After all, this is the new economy. Growth is here to stay, right? What goes up doesn't necessarily have to come down, right?
Wrong. This is exactly the kind of malarkey we heard during the internet bubble of the 90s. And just as internet skeptics were labeled as naysaying Chicken Littles then, the lonely skeptic in today's real estate boom is as unwelcome as common sense in a psychiatric ward.
But skepticism has aways been an important characteristic of the savvy investor - and savvy economists are starting to sound the alarm about housing. Cato Institute economist Dominick Armentano warns that "the real estate price bubble...risks sowing the seeds of the next business cycle downturn". More to the point, he writes: "the recent vast expansion in residential housing (and the increase in prices) mostly has been fueled by "easy money" from the Federal Reserve."
"Easy" money refers to the record low interest rates on everything from car loans to student loans to mortgages, all of which weigh heavily on the consumer side of the economy. And consumers are taking the plunge, unable to resist the temptation of 0% car payments and 6% home loans. They are overextending themselves to the point that any crack in income or employment levels would send many into bankruptcy.
"Irrational exuberance" (to borrow an earlier phrase from the anointed Alan Greenspan) among the home-buying crowd is fueling this inflationary housing market. But what's fueling the irrational exuberance in the first place? Cheap credit. And who's providing the cheap credit? That would be our beloved Greenspan. Though it may seem a bold statement, it is true that one man - Greenspan - is responsible for the housing bubble. This is because the Federal Reserve Bank is the single most influential institution in our economy, and Chairman Greenspan rules that institution largely unchallenged and with little oversight. Sure, he appears occasionally before the Senate, and like the Delphic Oracle delivers those famously opaque pronouncements. But his decisions on whether to raise or lower interest rates on us all is largely uninfluenced by any Senator, much less by any of his own colleauge at the Fed.
When home prices go up too fast, they will always come down. By the same token, when interest rates goes down, they will go back up. This trend will continue as Greenspan and Co. meet Tuesday to announce another rate spike. Let's all hope that spike isn't so sharp that it bursts our bubble.